315 lines
16 KiB
Markdown
315 lines
16 KiB
Markdown
**Hellenophobia** (also known as **Anti-Greek Sentiment**,
|
||
'''anti-Hellenism '''and **Mishellenism**) refers to
|
||
[racism](racism "wikilink"), negative feelings, dislike, hatred,
|
||
derision and/or prejudice towards Greeks or people of Greek descent.
|
||
|
||
## Historic Hellenophobia
|
||
|
||
### Ancient Rome
|
||
|
||
In the mid-Republican period Rome phil-Hellenic and anti-Hellenic Roman
|
||
intellectuals were involved in a conflict over Greek influence. One
|
||
author explains, "the relationship of Romans to Greek culture was
|
||
frequently ambiguous: they admired it as superior and adopted its
|
||
criteria, while they remained skeptical of some aspects; hence they
|
||
adapted it selectively according to their own purposes."<sup>\[9\]</sup>
|
||
An anti-Hellenic movement emerged in reaction to the primacy of Greek
|
||
led by the conservative and reactionary statesman Cato the Elder
|
||
(234-149 BCE), who was the first to write a Roman history in Latin, and
|
||
was prominent for his anti-Hellenic views.<sup>\[10\]\[11\]</sup> He saw
|
||
Hellenism a threat to Roman culture, but did not find wide support,
|
||
especially in the upper class.<sup>\[12\]</sup> However, Erich S. Gruen
|
||
argued that Cato's "anti-Greek 'pronouncements' reflect deliberate
|
||
posturing and do not represent 'the core of Catonian
|
||
thought'."<sup>\[13\]</sup> The prominent philosopher and politician
|
||
Cicero (106–43 BCE) was "highly ambivalent" about
|
||
Greeks,<sup>\[14\]</sup> and practiced "anti-Greek
|
||
slur".<sup>\[15\]</sup> The first-second century poet Juvenal was
|
||
another major anti-Hellenic figure.<sup>\[16\]\[17\]</sup>
|
||
|
||
### Latin West
|
||
|
||
Following the East–West Schism of 1054, anti-Greek sentiment became
|
||
widespread in the Latin West (dominated by the Catholic Church). It
|
||
reached its climax during the Fourth Crusade and the 1204 sack of
|
||
Constantinople, the Byzantine capital, and the establishment of the
|
||
Latin Empire.
|
||
|
||
### East Sicily and Malta
|
||
|
||
In East Sicily Malta, Christian Greeks were persecuted by Arabs during
|
||
the period of the Emirate of Sicily. And later Latin speaking Catholics
|
||
persecuted the Orthodox Greeks in Eastern Sicily and Arabic speaking
|
||
Catholics persecuted the Orthodox Greeks in Malta.
|
||
|
||
## Modern Hellenophobia
|
||
|
||
### Albania
|
||
|
||
In the Interwar period (1918–39), the Albanian government closed down
|
||
Greek schools as part of its policies of assimilation.<sup>\[19\]</sup>
|
||
During the Communist rule in Albania (1944–92), the government
|
||
restricted the use of Greek language and Greek names by the country's
|
||
Greek minority in an attempt of forced assimilation.<sup>\[20\]</sup>
|
||
Anti-Greek sentiment dominated the thinking of Enver Hoxha, the
|
||
communist leader of Albania, during the Greek Civil
|
||
War.<sup>\[21\]</sup>
|
||
|
||
In post-Communist Albania, "there are no significant explicitly racist
|
||
or chauvinist political parties", although, according to James Pettifer,
|
||
"there are many individual politicians who adhere to very strong
|
||
anti-Greek views, which in turn affects the orientation of virtually all
|
||
ethnic Albanian political parties."<sup>\[22\]</sup> In a 2013 poll in
|
||
Albania, Greece topped the list of countries perceived to be a threat to
|
||
Albania (18.5%), although the plurality of respondents (46.4%) agreed
|
||
with the statement "No country is a threat to Albania".<sup>\[23\]</sup>
|
||
|
||
### Australia
|
||
|
||
*Main Article: [Racism in Australia](Racism_in_Australia "wikilink")*
|
||
|
||
Greeks in [Australia](Australia "wikilink") have been subject to
|
||
discrimination. During [World War I](World_War_I "wikilink"), due to
|
||
King Constantine I's pro-German sympathies, Greek immigrants were viewed
|
||
with hostility and suspicion. Anti-Greek riots occurred in Perth in 1915
|
||
and in Kalgoorlie in 1916.
|
||
|
||
The word "wog" is an ethnic slur used in Australia to refer to Southern
|
||
European and Middle Eastern people of the Mediterranean region,
|
||
including Greeks. It is also sometimes used against South Asians. The
|
||
term has also been adopted and used by Greek Australians to refer to
|
||
themselves, including through the sitcom *Acropolis Now* (1989–92), the
|
||
television spin-off of the 1987 play *Wogs Out of Work* and the 2000
|
||
film *The Wog Boy*.
|
||
|
||
### Bulgaria
|
||
|
||
*Main Article: [Racism in Bulgaria](Racism_in_Bulgaria "wikilink")*
|
||
|
||
In 1906, during the Macedonian Struggle, anti-Greek rallies and violent
|
||
attacks took place in a number of Bulgarian cities. In Plovdiv, Greek
|
||
Orthodox churches and schools, Greek-owned properties were looted and
|
||
plundered. In Pomorie (Anchialos) the Greek population was expelled
|
||
after the city was set up on fire and up to 110 Greeks were killed.
|
||
Pogroms also took place in Varna, Burgas and other locations. Following
|
||
the pogroms, around 20,000 Greeks fled Bulgaria.
|
||
|
||
### Canada
|
||
|
||
*Main Article: [Racism in Canada](Racism_in_Canada "wikilink")*
|
||
|
||
On August 2–5, 1918, a three-day anti-Greek riot occurred in Toronto.
|
||
"Mobs of up to 5,000 people, led by war veterans returned from Europe,
|
||
marched through the city's main streets waging pitched battles with law
|
||
enforcement officers and destroying every Greek business they came
|
||
across." The consequence was damages of $100,000 to Greek businesses and
|
||
private property.
|
||
|
||
### Italy
|
||
|
||
*Main Article: [Racism in Italy](Racism_in_Italy "wikilink")*
|
||
|
||
When the Italian Fascists gained power in 1922, they persecuted the
|
||
Greek-speakers in Italy.
|
||
|
||
### Republic of North Macedonia
|
||
|
||
The Macedonia naming dispute since the breakup of Yugoslavia has given
|
||
rise to anti-Greek sentiment in the Republic of North
|
||
Macedonia.<sup>\[32\]</sup> According to one author, there was
|
||
"considerable popular anti-Greek feeling in Macedonia" as of
|
||
2004.<sup>\[33\]</sup> On the contrary, German diplomat Geert-Hinrich
|
||
Ahrens (ger) wrote in 2007 that he "had never detected any anti-Greek
|
||
manifestations" in the republic.<sup>\[34\]</sup>
|
||
|
||
The main opposition party of the Republic of North Macedonia, Internal
|
||
Macedonian Revolutionary Organization – Democratic Party for Macedonian
|
||
National Unity (VMRO-DPMNE), founded in 1990, includes the name of
|
||
Internal Macedonian Revolutionary Organization, a revolutionary movement
|
||
active in the early 20th century, which is regarded by Greeks "a
|
||
notorious anti-Greek terrorist organization."<sup>\[35\]</sup> During
|
||
the party's First Congress, Ljubčo Georgievski, first leader of the
|
||
party, declared that "the next Congress will convene in Solun"
|
||
(Thessaloniki in South Slavic languages).<sup>\[36\]</sup> According to
|
||
Dimitar Bechev, a British-based international relations researcher,
|
||
Macedonian Prime Minister Nikola Gruevski (the leader of VMRO-DPMNE)
|
||
exploited "anti-Greek nationalism" during the 2008 parliamentary
|
||
election.<sup>\[37\]</sup> In 2012 Gruevski accused Greece of having
|
||
waged "political genocide" against his country. Greek Foreign Ministry
|
||
spokesman Gregory Delavekouras responded that Gruevski's statements
|
||
"stoke the systematic negative government propaganda that is aimed at
|
||
turning public opinion in the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia
|
||
against Greece."<sup>\[38\]</sup>
|
||
|
||
### Romania
|
||
|
||
*Main Article: [Racism in Romania](Racism_in_Romania "wikilink")*
|
||
|
||
As Romanian nationalism grew overtime, a rift grew between Greece and
|
||
Romania. In 1892, Romania refused to hand over the property of the
|
||
recently deceased Greek expatriate Konstantinos Zappas to the Greek
|
||
state citing an article of the Romanian constitution forbidding foreign
|
||
nationals from owning agricultural land. The Trikoupis government then
|
||
recalled its ambassador in Bucharest, Romania followed suit thus
|
||
severing diplomatic relations between the countries. Diplomatic
|
||
relations were restored in July 1896, in response to a rise of Bulgarian
|
||
komitadji activity in Macedonia. In 1905, the two countries exchanged
|
||
accusations regarding the [Vlach Question](Vlach_Question "wikilink").
|
||
Romania claimed that Greek armed bands targeted ethnic Romanians in
|
||
Macedonia, whereas Greece accused Romania of trying to create a false
|
||
equation between Aromanians and Romanians.
|
||
|
||
Hellenophobic articles began appearing in the Romanian press. On 2
|
||
August 1905, the Society of Macedono–Romanian Culture organized an
|
||
anti–Greek protest in Bucharest, attended by army officers, student
|
||
and Vlachs. After decrying Greek war crimes in Macedonia, the organizers
|
||
called for a boycott of Greek products and services. Rioting was
|
||
prevented by a large force of Romanian police. On the same day a Greek
|
||
owned cafe in Bucharest was vandalized and its owner beaten. Several
|
||
days later three editors of the Greek language newspaper Patris were
|
||
expelled from the country for sedition. On 13 August, protesters burnt a
|
||
Greek flag in Giurgiu. An official remonstrance by the Greek ambassador
|
||
Tombazis was rebutted leading to a mutual withdrawal of embassies on 15
|
||
September. In November, the Romanian government allocated funding for
|
||
the creation of armed Aromanian bands in Macedonia, a parallel motion
|
||
closed numerous Greek schools in the country. In February 1906, six
|
||
leading members of the Greek community were expelled from the country,
|
||
citing their alleged funding of Greek bands in Macedonia. In July 1906,
|
||
the Greek government officially severed diplomatic relations with
|
||
Romania. In 1911, Greek prime minister Eleftherios Venizelos used the
|
||
occasion of the Italo-Turkish War to improve relations with Bulgaria and
|
||
Romania, restoring diplomatic relations with the latter.
|
||
|
||
### Soviet Union
|
||
|
||
*Main Article: [Racism in the USSR](Racism_in_the_USSR "wikilink")*
|
||
|
||
Between 1919 and 1924 around 47,000 Greeks emigrated from
|
||
[Russia](Russian_Empire "wikilink") to [Greece](Greece "wikilink") as a
|
||
result of the official and unofficial anti-Greek sentiment in
|
||
[Russia](Russia "wikilink"), which in its turn was a result of the Greek
|
||
intervention in the Black Sea region in the [Russian Civil
|
||
War](Russian_Civil_War "wikilink") against the
|
||
[Bolsheviks](Bolsheviks "wikilink"). Tens of thousands of Greeks were
|
||
deported to the remote parts of the Soviet Union during [World War
|
||
II](World_War_II "wikilink") in the [Greek Operation of
|
||
NKVD](Greek_Operation_\(USSR\) "wikilink").
|
||
|
||
### Turkey
|
||
|
||
*Main Article: [Racism in Turkey](Racism_in_Turkey "wikilink")*
|
||
|
||
A 2011 survey in Turkey revealed that 67% of respondents had unfavorable
|
||
views toward Greeks, although only 6% of Turks said Greece was their
|
||
country's main enemy in a poll carried out in the same year. Journalist
|
||
Dr. Cenk Saraçoğlu of Ankara University argues that anti-Greek attitudes
|
||
in Turkey "are no longer constructed and shaped by social interactions
|
||
between the 'ordinary people' Rather, the Turkish media and state
|
||
promote and disseminate an overtly anti-Greek discourse." Although
|
||
others have argued anti-Greek sentiment is decreasing as appreciation
|
||
for Greek culture grows.
|
||
|
||
During and following [World War I](World_War_I "wikilink"), almost all
|
||
of the [Greek population of Anatolia was either
|
||
exterminated](Greek_Genocide_\(1910s\) "wikilink") by the Ottoman
|
||
government or later transferred to Greece as part of a population
|
||
exchange. In September 1955 the Turkish government sponsored [anti-Greek
|
||
riots and pogrom in Istanbul](Istanbul_Pogrom_\(1955\) "wikilink"). The
|
||
[conflict over Cyprus](Cyprus_Conflict "wikilink") kept anti-Greek
|
||
feelings in Turkey high. At the height of the intercommunal violence in
|
||
Cyprus, thousands of Greeks were expelled from Turkey, mostly Istanbul.
|
||
In March of that year all persons (over 6,000) with Greek citizenship
|
||
were expelled "on the grounds that they were dangerous to the 'internal
|
||
and external' security of the state." Additionally, in September 1964,
|
||
10,000 Greeks were expelled. Around 30,000 "Turkish nationals of Greek
|
||
descent had left permanently, in addition to the Greeks who had been
|
||
expelled." Within months a total of 40,000 Greeks were expelled from
|
||
Istanbul.
|
||
|
||
In 1999 Turkey was again swept by a wave of anti-Greek sentiment,
|
||
encouraged by the Turkish government following the capture of the
|
||
[Kurdistan Workers' Party](Kurdistan_Workers'_Party "wikilink") leader
|
||
[Abdullah Öcalan](Abdullah_Öcalan "wikilink"). However, as a result of
|
||
the "earthquake diplomacy" and the subsequent rapprochement efforts
|
||
between Greece and Turkey, the public perception of Greece as their main
|
||
enemy decreased in Turkey from 29% in 2001 to 16.9% in 2004.
|
||
|
||
The [Grey Wolves](Grey_Wolves_\(Turkey\) "wikilink"), a far-right
|
||
organization associated with the Nationalist Movement Party (MHP),
|
||
routinely demonstrate outside the Ecumenical Patriarchate of
|
||
Constantinople in Fener (Phanar), Istanbul and burn the Patriarch in
|
||
effigy. In October 2005 they staged a rally and proceeding to the gate
|
||
they laid a black wreath, chanting "Patriarch Leave" and "Patriarchate
|
||
to Greece", inaugurating the campaign for the collection of signatures
|
||
to oust the Ecumenical Patriarchate from Istanbul. As of 2006 the Grey
|
||
Wolves claimed to have collected more than 5 million signatures for the
|
||
withdrawal of the Patriarch and called on the Turkish government to have
|
||
the patriarch deported to Greece.
|
||
|
||
### United States
|
||
|
||
*Main Article: [Racism in the USA](Racism_in_the_USA "wikilink")*
|
||
|
||
In the early 20th century Greeks in the United States were discriminated
|
||
against in many ways. In 1904 Greek immigrants, unaware of labor
|
||
conditions and largely inexperienced, served as strikebreakers during a
|
||
strike in Chicago diesel shops. This fueled anti-Greek sentiment among
|
||
union members. Three Greek immigrants were killed during a riot in 1908
|
||
in McGill, Nevada. On February 21, 1909, a major anti-Greek riot took
|
||
place in South Omaha, Nebraska. The Greek population was forced to leave
|
||
the city, while properties owned by Greek migrants were destroyed.
|
||
Greeks were viewed with particular contempt in the Mormon stronghold of
|
||
Utah. The local press characterized them as "a vicious element unfit for
|
||
citizenship and as ignorant, depraved, and brutal foreigners."
|
||
Anti-Greek riots occurred in Salt Lake City in 1917 which "almost
|
||
resulted" in lynching of a Greek immigrant. In 1922, as a response to
|
||
the anti-Greek nativist xenophobia by the [Ku Klux
|
||
Klan](Ku_Klux_Klan "wikilink") (KKK), the American Hellenic Educational
|
||
Progressive Association (AHEPA) was founded, which sought to Americanize
|
||
the Greek immigrant in America.
|
||
|
||
In December 2014 MTV aired the first episode of its new reality show
|
||
*Growing Up Greek*. It was immediately denounced by Greek Americans and
|
||
characterized as "stereotype-laden" and "offensive". The American
|
||
Hellenic Educational Progressive Association (AHEPA) called for it to be
|
||
canceled.
|
||
|
||
### Western Europe
|
||
|
||
*Main Articles: [Racism in Germany](Racism_in_Germany "wikilink") and
|
||
[Racism in the UK](Racism_in_the_UK "wikilink")*
|
||
|
||
As a result of the Greek government-debt crisis, starting in 2010,
|
||
anti-Greek sentiments grew in some European countries, especially in
|
||
Germany.<sup>\[64\]\[65\]\[66\]</sup> A 2014 study found, "An anti-Greek
|
||
sentiment evolved and spread among German citizens and solidarity for
|
||
crisis-hit Greece was mostly rejected."<sup>\[67\]</sup> In 2012 Pew
|
||
Research Center found, "Among the major European countries, Greece is
|
||
clearly the least popular. And its reputation is slipping. In no
|
||
country, other than Greece itself, is there a majority with a favorable
|
||
view of Greece." Only 27% of respondents in Germany viewed Greece
|
||
favorably.<sup>\[68\]</sup>
|
||
|
||
Hostile and unfavorable views towards Greece and Greeks were especially
|
||
pronounced in the tabloid press. A 2013 study found that "British and
|
||
German news sources indicate bias against Greece in financial crisis
|
||
coverage, although likely with important differences; both, however,
|
||
include stereotypes, the recommendation of austerity as a punishment,
|
||
morality tales, an absence of solidarity, and fear
|
||
mongering."<sup>\[69\]</sup> The popular German tabloid *Bild*
|
||
"published numerous reports that implicitly and explicitly constituted
|
||
the myth of the corrupt and lazy Greeks in comparison to the
|
||
hard-working Germans."<sup>\[67\]</sup> Dutch TV producer Ingeborg
|
||
Beugel (nl) claimed that "the \[anti-Greek\] propaganda of the
|
||
mainstream media provides Europe and the Netherlands with a convenient
|
||
scapegoat to exploit."<sup>\[70\]</sup>
|
||
|
||
German politicians, such as Foreign Minister Guido Westerwelle and
|
||
former Chancellor Gerhard Schröder, publicly criticized the anti-Greek
|
||
sentiment in their country and called for solidarity with
|
||
Greece.<sup>\[71\]\[72\]\[73\]</sup>
|
||
|
||
## References
|
||
|
||
[Wikipedia](Wikipedia "wikilink") - [Anti-Greek
|
||
sentiment](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Greek_sentiment) |