342 lines
23 KiB
Markdown
342 lines
23 KiB
Markdown
You must help yourself: Neo-liberal geographies and worker insurgency in
|
||
Osaka.
|
||
|
||
## Background
|
||
|
||
October 2nd, 1990. The day started as any other does in Osaka's
|
||
Nishi-Nari ward, men lined up around the yoseba employment center, in
|
||
the thousands, waiting for work. If it came, they would load into the
|
||
cars of construction contractors in groups, with parachute pants and
|
||
wrapped heads. For eight hours they might wave light wands 'guiding
|
||
pedestrians', dig concrete roads, re-pave highways or variously break
|
||
their backs in the sun. This proletarian fate was ceded by the city's
|
||
bourgeoisie over a period of thirty years of continuous unemployed
|
||
unrest; all the union officials touted it as labor 'won' from an inhuman
|
||
system. After all, without work, one does not eat, and once conditions
|
||
have worsened to the point that this phrase becomes dictatorial, one
|
||
works in a fervor; for work leads to 'independence'. Work might one day
|
||
lead out of the slum. If work didn't come, the men wait out lunch and
|
||
line up for the daily workfare handout, set aside for 'unsuccessful
|
||
job-seekers'. This yoseba is in Kamagasaki, a neighborhood of poverty
|
||
and celebration, a breathing lung, where the yakuza patrol day-workers
|
||
with icy looks and stashed weapons; at occupied 'triangle' park, men,
|
||
dogs and blue canvas spill out into the street sides. Udon and soba are
|
||
served at improvised stool stands roofed with canvas. Women and men
|
||
prepare boxed lunches, noodles and Okinawan fare at shops lining the
|
||
crowded avenues. Just to the east the brothel neighborhood of Tobita
|
||
sits in expectant dormancy, for the night will soon fall. The slum is
|
||
quiet. For the city hall and the construction capitalists, it was just
|
||
another Tuesday. There were multiple flashpoints, like any riot, origins
|
||
that became history for the individuals and groups that experienced
|
||
them. For most, the riots began with friends running past, heaving
|
||
paving stones at the police. But most will point to an account of an old
|
||
homeless man in the Namba theater district, north of Kamagasaki. Police
|
||
on patrol had stopped at his improvised blue canvas house, berating him
|
||
to leave the sidewalk. The man (known by most as 'a bit bizarre')
|
||
unleashed his dog, which quickly sunk its teeth into a senior patrolman.
|
||
After a struggle, he was surrounded by police and beaten as a crowd
|
||
gathered, consisting of other homeless people and some day-workers.
|
||
Hauled away and arrested, the angry crowd followed the car to the
|
||
Nishinari police station.\[1\] News spread on sprinting legs to the
|
||
enormous yoseba hiring hall in the south, circulating among groups of
|
||
day laborers. Without any particular confrontation, a few 'troublesome'
|
||
workers were pulled aside by the yoseba police patrol and in front of
|
||
thousands, beaten. The neighborhood exploded. Yoseba day-workers,
|
||
witnesses in their thousands, took their comrades back and drove the
|
||
police from the hiring hall, swarming outward like blood through
|
||
Kamagasaki's lungs. Crowds formed here and there, with a general
|
||
movement towards the police station, from which the police re-emerged. A
|
||
rain of stones fell. After the volleys reached a temporary abatement,
|
||
barricades were quickly erected, bicycles ignited with cheap lighter
|
||
fluid, stacked and burned, dumpsters dragged into the street.
|
||
<em>Capital's tendency to crisis, the proletarian form, was
|
||
erupting.</em>
|
||
|
||
The police retreated in order to barricade the neighborhoods, to shut
|
||
off the arteries that connect Kamagasaki to the north, south, east and
|
||
west.\[2\] A classic siege strategy was put into action punctuated by
|
||
sudden, violent streams of steel-shield armed police into the
|
||
neighborhoods. Mobile riot squads surrounded the area with armored buses
|
||
and paddy wagons, and soon lined the boulevards in columns with five
|
||
foot steel shields. All the forces of government and private capital
|
||
arrived to contain thousands of revolting workers and rapidly arriving
|
||
allies, to circumscribe a space that was impassable for the surging rage
|
||
of the rioters. Media vans pulled up and were stoned if they attempted
|
||
to penetrate the riot line and 'get the real story'. In several cases
|
||
cameras were sought after and smashed.\[3\] All footage of the events
|
||
comes from behind police lines. Advances by the cops were met with
|
||
volleys of objects flung from the parapets of apartment buildings by the
|
||
unemployed, workers and housewives. At times, the riot constituted
|
||
itself as a castle pocked with archers. When the first barricaded day
|
||
slipped into night, the cars of the construction barons were smashed and
|
||
degraded. Parks that had been evicted of squatters had their locks
|
||
broken and were re-taken. The insurrection faced its own limit, against
|
||
the borders of space drawn by the state and its own projectuality.
|
||
Discussions arose everywhere on where to go next. Many feared that the
|
||
riotous action would blacklist the neighborhood from construction
|
||
contracts, that the yoseba would close like the one in Tokyo had just a
|
||
year earlier, that poverty would worsen. Most gazed over the surrounding
|
||
steel buses of the riot police and saw the impossibility of expansion,
|
||
of the riot spreading to other sectors. NGO workers and city hall
|
||
mediators arrived urging people to 'calm down', that police violence
|
||
could be 'addressed'. But these particular beatings were only moments on
|
||
a continuum of violent surveillance and control. There was no doubt that
|
||
the situation was in fact rapidly worsening as police ran wild in the
|
||
streets, smashing skulls and faces with steel pipes and shields. The
|
||
Kamagasaki population was at open revolt with the organs of repression,
|
||
most saw no way back to 'normality'.\[4\] Buses and sound-cars of the
|
||
unions and organizations of the unemployed mobilized from their garages
|
||
and circled the neighborhood, providing a temporary barrier; they
|
||
eventually moving through police lines, broadcasting messages to a wider
|
||
portion of the city. Night fell again. "I edged back to the crowd. From
|
||
behind me, someone yelled 'Aim for the lights\!'. Stones were thrown
|
||
aiming towards the lights of TV cameras stationed behind the riot squad.
|
||
I entered the crowd. No one took any notice of the camera that I held in
|
||
my hand. After a while, a man spoke to me. 'Are you from the news
|
||
papers?' When I answered no, he said, 'If you are, you are going to get
|
||
killed.'" <em>-anonymous observer at Kamagasaki</em> As the riot
|
||
entered into its third, fourth day the city's strategy was in continual
|
||
escalation. The rioting, unarmed workers were meat for the mobile riot
|
||
squads. Largely defensive formations changed into charges, five-foot
|
||
steel shields were leveled against the flesh of the disgusted.
|
||
Barricades collapsed or were extinguished, and the police made real
|
||
progress into the neighborhoods. If the streets could be cleared, then
|
||
the tear-gas buses and paddy wagons could move in. Hundreds of the most
|
||
militant were chased south into a union building where the insurrection
|
||
made its last, unarmed stand. Concurrently and further south, partly in
|
||
inspiration from the Kamagasaki rebellion, a youth revolt had exploded,
|
||
spearheaded by 'speed tribe' gangs on motorcycles who fought the police
|
||
in skirmishes. This rebellion was contained even quicker, and most of
|
||
the young rioters found themselves chased into the same building with
|
||
the older workers. There would be no cavalry for Kamagasaki. The
|
||
building was taken with tremendous violence. The 22nd riot in the
|
||
neighborhood's 30 year history had ended. Despite the arrest and
|
||
imprisonment of many, over the next four years there would be more small
|
||
riots, sporadically, where the police or contractors were targeted. When
|
||
unrest broke out, other workers would come running; construction
|
||
contractors dodging back-wages found themselves at the mercy of mobs.
|
||
People took inspiration from the riots that raged through the
|
||
neighborhoods throughout the 1960s, contestation, above all was the
|
||
agenda\! The strategy against the riot by the city and the bourgeoisie
|
||
was drawn from every lesson learned in the past forty years of class
|
||
struggle in post-fordist Japan. Initial direct force, followed by the
|
||
deployment of mediators, the deployment of advanced technological means
|
||
of repression, filtering of news about the riots, news blackouts,
|
||
concluding in total geographical isolation of the proletarian ferment.
|
||
Riots can not be permitted to spread to other sectors, and therefore
|
||
Japanese capital's only strategy against the eruption of its own
|
||
contradictions is containment. MUZZLED CONTRADICTIONS, STRANGLED
|
||
PROLETARIANS The riots of the 1990s took place amid the massive
|
||
restructuring of the 1980s and the economic crisis of 1989 as the
|
||
investment 'bubble' burst and the promise of a Japanese 'prosperity'
|
||
proved hollow. Already migrant workers from Okinawa and Tokyo had taken
|
||
up park occupations all over Osaka, not to mention Nishi-nari ward and
|
||
the Kamagasaki neighborhood. Improvised huts, roofed with blue tarp,
|
||
decorated with paint, junk, sometimes city free jazz schedules and at
|
||
the very least posters of famous female crooners holding beer mugs,
|
||
sprung up all over the city. The huts were statements of autonomy,
|
||
arising from the immediate inability of newly-arrived workers to afford
|
||
housing; as a strategy the 'tent villages' blanketed the city, in order
|
||
to stake out an existence independent of the welfare state's
|
||
institutionalization. Out of the riots, the workers' movement in
|
||
Kamagasaki re-composed into union coalitions. NGOs replaced the direct
|
||
discipline of police batons as their mediating roles were appreciated by
|
||
the city in halting unrest. 16 surveillance cameras at major
|
||
intersections and shopping streets were installed in Kamagasaki alone.
|
||
Over 1990-1995, the men at city hall dumped all the previous strategies,
|
||
and Kamagasaki moved from a zone of discipline to one of control, from
|
||
containment of outburst to total regulation; the unemployed were
|
||
channeled, mediated and surveilled like never before; what could once
|
||
communicate itself as a struggle of autonomy against the control
|
||
apparatus was now more and more forced to speak the language of social
|
||
peace.\[5\] Park occupations were slowly apologized for as a response to
|
||
the poverty of the city's institutional shelters as well as the lack of
|
||
viable jobs, instead of their obvious essence, areas autonomous from
|
||
capitalist time, characterized by relaxation, karaoke songs and games
|
||
like go and shogi. The occupations were attempts to attain a moderately
|
||
bourgeois standard of living, actualizing in motion, against an ocean of
|
||
industrial poverty.\[6\] Continual violence and harassment by yakuza and
|
||
police managed to dull the direct-action strategy of spiteful
|
||
day-workers as well as the heaviest strategies by newly radicalized
|
||
unions, who quickly transformed into facilitators of ritual action: such
|
||
as protest marches completely surrounded by police, food handouts and
|
||
supplication to city officials at any level of struggle. "As real
|
||
subsumption advanced it appeared that the mediations of the existence of
|
||
the class in the capitalist mode of production, far from being exterior
|
||
to the 'being' of the class which must affirm itself against them, were
|
||
nothing but this being in movement, in its necessary implication with
|
||
the other pole of society, capital." <em>- Theorie Communiste</em>
|
||
NEO-LIBERALISM: TRANSFORMED EXPLOITATION, TRANSFORMED GEOGRAPHIES
|
||
Outside of Kamagasaki and Osaka, across the social terrain of Japan, the
|
||
neo-liberal project had been advancing at least since the collapse of
|
||
the new left in the late 1970s. A near collapse of the social safety net
|
||
ensued: previous welfare guarantees were transformed increasingly into
|
||
workfare, an entire landlord class was born atop workfare-registered
|
||
workers struggling to pay 'discounted' rents on yoseba wages. The
|
||
retirement age was officially moved from 60 to 65 for most businesses in
|
||
2005, completing an already unofficial shift planned long-term by the
|
||
LDP; a whole generation of parents suddenly found themselves working
|
||
longer and harder and by desperation turning their children's' schools
|
||
into factories for the production of workers who could support them
|
||
post-retirement, as pension guarantees seemed bound for an irreversible
|
||
crisis. Elderly workers who laid-off in the crisis often found
|
||
themselves on the street with no employment prospects. Among the
|
||
bourgeoisie, support for privatization and the gradual wearing away of
|
||
the 'welfare state' gained steam. Nothing characterized the period more
|
||
than speed-up. With the unification in the late 60s of train lines
|
||
around the country under the JR Company and the rapid acceleration of
|
||
bullet train technology, capital smoothed space towards a white plane,
|
||
one with no resistance to the circulation of raw materials, labor power
|
||
and surplus value. Highways brought the same changes, and inside the
|
||
workplace a collapse of the labor movement ensured human beings snared
|
||
in 60-70 hour weeks became the norm for full-time employees. The
|
||
individual experience of labor became more and more an endless conveyor
|
||
belt between home, transit and the workplace. A metropolitan factory
|
||
modeled on assembly lines, bound by its very constitution, to disaster.
|
||
ENCLOSURE, SPEED, DISASTER As an island chain along major fault lines,
|
||
Japanese civilization is fraught with constant disaster. The 1995
|
||
earthquake in Kobe was only the most recent massive demonstration of the
|
||
power of continental plates (5,273 people were killed, most crushed to
|
||
death in the collapse of their houses or consumed by the fires that
|
||
followed the earthquake, 96.3 billion dollars of damage were assessed).
|
||
Earthquakes are phantoms, haunting all considerations of the future.
|
||
Last December, a scandal broke in the news media; Hidetsugu Aneha, a 48
|
||
year old architect working at a construction firm called Hyuza in Tokyo
|
||
had, under pressure from his superiors to cut costs on the buildings he
|
||
was designing, reduced steel reinforcements in building skeletons and
|
||
falsified data to cover his tracks. As his actions were uncovered and an
|
||
investigation was launched by the city, it came out that the building
|
||
for which design statistics had been falsified was not a lone example;
|
||
the number quickly mushroomed, resulted in the implication of 78 hotels
|
||
and buildings as being at 30-80% of minimal earthquake preparedness,
|
||
meaning likely collapse during a strong earthquake. In his defense Aneha
|
||
protested that when he raised these issues to his superiors they told
|
||
him the firm would simply lose the contract to other firms if proper
|
||
costs were covered, and so he must cut expenses any way he could;
|
||
Aneha's comments therefore implicate not only himself and his
|
||
corporation, but the construction industry as a whole. These vast,
|
||
condensed metropolises of the Japanese islands contain millions of
|
||
bodies on foundations increasingly precarious, and despite the
|
||
spectacular efforts by city governments at reform and revision,
|
||
thousands will not survive the next earthquake (as many were killed in
|
||
recent Niigata prefecture earthquakes). Capitalism has developed all
|
||
formalized dwellings, all massive dormitories of the exploited that
|
||
stretch from the city to suburbia, into potential coffins. In ironic
|
||
contrast stand the humble hut-dwelling day-workers of Osaka whose
|
||
low-impact 'outside dwellings' are in no danger of killing them during a
|
||
disaster. In 1987, Japan's nationalized train lines were divided into
|
||
west and east and privatized. Adding a profit motive to trains, already
|
||
circulating on the rhythm of breakneck post-Fordist Japanese capitalism,
|
||
guaranteed the narrowing of bottom lines and an amplified pursuit of
|
||
speed between stations. In 2005, a rush-hour train derailed between
|
||
Amagasaki station and Takaradsuka station north of Osaka. The young
|
||
train driver had been berated repeatedly by supervisors and his
|
||
supervising senior driver to cut seven minutes off of the recommended
|
||
transit time for the 25 km between these two stations. The train
|
||
derailed, traveling at a tremendous speed and collided with a large
|
||
apartment building, destroying part of its foundation and causing the
|
||
building to collapse on top of the train car. 105 people died either
|
||
instantly or before rescue workers could reach them. Unfortunately for
|
||
the bureaucrats and company officials rolled out to the scene to beg
|
||
apology (and for all who ride these trains) no uptake of individual
|
||
responsibility for this massacre can erase the obvious but unspeakable
|
||
culpability of the economy, cloud of massified instrumental necessity,
|
||
which by shearing away life-time from the individual worker according to
|
||
its internal pressure, must constantly flirt with cheap materials and
|
||
disastrous speed. The reaction of the individual: 'Where is my train? My
|
||
son is waiting.' gives form to this pressure. Universal demand for the
|
||
reduction of transit time, born out of the stubborn intransigence of
|
||
work time, pushes the trains faster and faster. The social pressure of
|
||
work time against life time produces derailments, just as the concrete
|
||
capitalist organization of geography ensures this acceleratory dynamic
|
||
across space. Crisis is therefore implicit in the accumulated forms of
|
||
capitalist working class subsumption. To which again, capital can only
|
||
respond with containment. "When the ship goes down, so too do the first
|
||
class passengers... The ruling class, for its part incapable of
|
||
struggling against the devil of business activity, superproduction and
|
||
superconstruction for its own skin, thus demonstrates the end of its
|
||
control over society, and it is foolish to expect that, in the name of a
|
||
progress with its trail indicated by bloodstains, it can produce safer
|
||
(trains) than those of the past..." <em>-Amadeo Bordiga, Murdering the
|
||
Dead</em> DISINTEGRATING WORKPLACES; ANTAGONISTIC SPACES During the
|
||
neo-liberal wave, an expansion of 'irregular employment' brought about
|
||
the birth of a precarious class of workers that would precede Europe's
|
||
'precariat' in conditions if not consciousness. It would also create new
|
||
forms of social labor that were 'out', roving the cities.\[7\] Inside
|
||
workplaces, an increasing concentration of fixed capital within
|
||
factories accompanied by off-shoring meant that Japanese government had
|
||
a mostly idle labor force, steadily being undermined in its real
|
||
conditions of subsistence by welfare reform, one that could be put to
|
||
work in entirely new 'service' industries. Jobs were invented. Escalator
|
||
girls, elevator girls, kyaku-hiki (customer pullers), street megaphones,
|
||
flyering, etc. new 'services' that were above all 'out and about',
|
||
social forms that seized forms of inter-human sociality, the tap on the
|
||
shoulder, the kind holding of the elevator door, the smile, amplifying
|
||
them, valorizing what had been mostly unwaged action. Population shifts
|
||
led to the unavoidable importation of foreign labor, causing a gradual
|
||
cosmopolitanization that has thrown the idea of a 'Japanese' identity
|
||
into crisis, while also strengthening reactionary ideologies that take
|
||
strength from it. The growth of an English education industry brought
|
||
thousands of temporary workers to Japan, and with them, historical
|
||
methods of class struggle that clashed strongly with Japanese welfare
|
||
state compromises of the 70s and 80s. As capitalists continually sought
|
||
to preclude the ability of foreign labor to organize itself, the
|
||
workplace form quickly dissolved from private schools to dispatch
|
||
offices, private lessons in libraries, citizen halls, cafes everywhere.
|
||
In a unique way, this foreign labor also became 'out', dislocated,
|
||
social. To contain these new socialities arising across old geographies,
|
||
the police and city planners are continuously at work. In late 2003, the
|
||
already barricaded and privatized Tennoji Park in Osaka was invaded by
|
||
300 riot police who had come to evict what was known as the 'karaoke
|
||
village', a large area of the park taken over by karaoke carts, venders
|
||
and crooners, gathering point for hundreds of day-workers daily who
|
||
belted out song classics after work. For forty years the plaza was a
|
||
hot-spot, even tourist attraction known as the 'soul of Osaka', a
|
||
musical space occupied by the downtrodden, who sunk into song and drink,
|
||
dulling the pain, remembering more riotous times. In December 2003 the
|
||
riot police moved in and barricaded the park for 'construction
|
||
purposes'. Vendors and crooners showed up in hundreds to watch the
|
||
demolition and vent their rage. Barricades were thrown at the police,
|
||
but the disobedients were quickly arrested. There would be no repeat of
|
||
October 1990. All that is left of the karaoke village now is a steel
|
||
fence, wrapping a completely empty lot. The park is silent. Osaka city
|
||
now plans a wave of evictions of squatters from parks all over its map.
|
||
The first of the year is already underway in mid-city, and the park's
|
||
residents are crouched down, preparing to resist the riot squads. The
|
||
proletarians of Osaka's wards must learn the lessons of the past:
|
||
against the brutal technological barricades of the riot police,
|
||
surveillance and containment, they must adapt an improvised, mobile
|
||
capability. The riots around Clichy-sous-bois provide a possible source
|
||
of inspiration, totally mobile, skirmish-based attack, no commitments,
|
||
no demands as such. No gathering points and thus no encirclement, no
|
||
containment. Also in question is how social space can be re-worked and
|
||
decelerated, how an autonomous space can develop against the crushing
|
||
weight of capitalism, while simultaneously understanding its own
|
||
limitations, how we might 'help ourselves' to a future that doubtlessly
|
||
awaits us if we seek it.\[8\] The strange new crisis-ridden social
|
||
geographies of post-fordist capitalism offer gates for the fleeing
|
||
proletariat, which now finds itself everywhere. FOOTNOTES 1 It was
|
||
revealed earlier that week that the police chief in Nishinari had been
|
||
taking bribes from Yakuza gangs for a variety of 'favors'. 2 Except for
|
||
the Yakuza gangs who had all run away from the scene. 3 The information
|
||
sharing grid between media, yakuza and government is well known in most
|
||
parts of the islands. 4 Some of these older workers had cut their teeth
|
||
on the anti-Yakuza struggles of the 1980s in Tokyo's Sanya district,
|
||
some who were ex-members of militant groups like the red army, some who
|
||
had served prison time for throwing bombs at police in the 60s.
|
||
Incidentally, the Kamagasaki revolt was a big inspiration for Otomo
|
||
Katsuhiro's Akira. 5 NGO workers can now be seen every day on the
|
||
winding employment lines, monitoring workers with friendly armbands that
|
||
say 'safety patrol'\! 6 Some hut plots in the autonomous parks have
|
||
gorgeous gardens growing in them, in one case an occupant had improvised
|
||
a permaculture system, with over-arching grape vines shading greens
|
||
below and tomatoes flanking. 7 Many factory jobs were also shipped to
|
||
East Asia at this time. 8 One phenomenon that may offer inspiration on
|
||
this point: in Tennoji park, the same park that has been fenced and
|
||
barricaded, robbed of most autonomy, two homeless men living in the
|
||
lower part of the park have set out before their home five comfortable
|
||
leather chairs, apparently open to anyone to sit in, chat or play go.
|
||
The path on which these men live and on which their chairs are situated
|
||
is a vital walking path for commuters, who everyday gaze curiously or
|
||
longingly at these lounging non-workers, these jesters of the free
|
||
community. from an anonymously published article in datacide magazine. |